12 min read

...and What Indie Filmmakers Can Do About It (Theatrical Distribution Part 2)

...and What Indie Filmmakers Can Do About It (Theatrical Distribution Part 2)
The end card of the Brotherhood Trailer

A few months ago I told you I'd tell you exactly how our theatrical release went. I'm now at the point where I can do that.

The short version: it didn't go as planned. Here's what we did about it.

In Part 1, I ended on this: theaters don't book demand, they book certainty, and certainty has to come from somewhere. No one else in the process of releasing your movie is going to create it for you. So if theaters book certainty, the independent's job is to manufacture it.

Filmmakers tend to think their job is to make the movie, and that they can hand the responsibility for distribution, marketing and even financial recoupment to someone else. My argument is that any producer who raises money is responsible for paying that investment back – in fact, that's your number one responsibility. The way you do that is marketing and sales.

The plan

Our plan started with a three-week marketing tour: 16 cities and three premieres, 19 events in September, to get thousands of people wanting to see this movie in theaters when it came out.

We originally planned to open October 2nd. Our PR team and our distributor both told us October 9th would be better – it would give the press time to write about the premieres and get those stories live, and when we had that conversation in early September, October 9th looked like a less busy weekend. So we switched, and that's the date we promoted publicly for about a month.

The goal for the tour was a list of 5,000 to 10,000 people. We were expecting 300 to 500 people per event, and we booked rooms with hundreds of seats. Out of those events, I hoped to pre-sell 5,000 to 10,000 tickets. The goal was 10,000, because I knew if we had that, we could leverage it into distribution.

The distribution plan was 20 to 25 cities: several in Utah, plus the tour cities where we had our audience. One theater per city, so we'd intentionally limit the supply and be oversubscribed, with the goal of selling out every show.

Here's why that matters: even at one showtime a day, a sold-out room of 100 seats is about $1,500. Do that seven times and it's $10,500 in a week, and we'd have been one of the top three movies in any theater the weeks we came out. Ten thousand pre-sold tickets would have meant a six-figure opening weekend on 20 to 25 screens. That was the target: a really high per-screen average on opening weekend, then use it to get into more theaters.

What happened

Our first tour stop went really well. Nearly five hundred people came out in Provo to kick it off, and it was a wonderful event. We were getting really excited.

Overall, though, 2,641 people RSVP'd to the different events, and around 800 people actually came out to the tour, not 5,000 to 10,000, and not even 2,000 to 5,000. That's fewer than we expected for our marketing spend and all the promotion we did.

What we ended up with is still great: nearly 2,000 requests to see the movie in theaters (and counting) and about 850 pre-sold tickets from the tour, over a thousand in all. It would have been great to have ten times that.

The biggest failure of all was that our theatrical booker didn't get us 20 screens. Not 10. Not two. We got one showtime at one theater, in a city outside the tour city we'd been to. That said, we had a great turnout for that one showtime!

According to the booker, there were no screens available. The big national chains we went to first, asking to do all 20 cities with one circuit, all passed.

So all things considered, a massive swing and a miss on distribution, and a much smaller turnout on the tour than we'd prepared for. It was discouraging that it didn't work the way we hoped.

So I ended our agreement with the distributor and the booker, and on October 14th, the Wednesday after opening weekend, I took over theatrical booking myself. To be clear, that was not in the plan.

The first call

That Thursday I had calls with friends in distribution, and a lunch the following Monday. What I understood from those calls is that it's possible, it's hard, and it's a relationship game. I was going to have some hard conversations, and some people wouldn't get back to me because they'd never worked with me before.

I decided to just dive in and start calling.

I was dreading it a bit. Will they answer my calls? Am I going to be able to pull this off?

The first call went something like: "Hey, it's Daren Smith. I've taken over booking for Brotherhood. Looks like we did well with the one showtime we had. I'd love to talk to you about a holdover or a first run of the film."

He answered my first call, and he responded positively. He said they couldn't do it in that theater, but they could move us to a different theater nearby with more screens and run it there. He wouldn't budge on the matinee time slot or the 35% split, so it wasn't the best deal for us. I think we ended up making a few hundred dollars that week. Live and learn.

But... it showed me it was possible! I was so grateful that first call went well, instead of hitting a voicemail and getting no response for weeks.

And what I realized is that there was more availability in the marketplace than our distributor had led me to believe. On the first call, I booked a first run off that opening weekend result. Over the next few days I booked the rest. Between October 14th and the 22nd, I booked 10 new first-run engagements, some of them with mid-tier chains like Starlight, Santikos, Megaplex and Harkins. To go from one showtime in one theater to 10 bookings is a big deal for a first-time booker who'd never worked with any of these people.

Manufacturing certainty

The moment I saw the plan actually work was when some of those bigger chains, Santikos, Megaplex and Starlight, responded to me sending them proof of demand: how many pre-sold tickets, and how many requests for their theater specifically.

It didn't require the audience to call the theaters and ask for the movie. I had the proof, because we built the demand pages and the request pages so we could show anyone, anytime, where the demand is and what's still unfulfilled.

That's the certainty a theater needs. It's on a DCP... It's being delivered by a trusted source... The audience is already there, and here's the number...

We lined it up for a new release date of October 30th and called October 9th our preview. A theater 20 to 30 minutes outside Provo had reached out to me directly before opening weekend, and I passed it to our booker. They held us for the week of the ninth, with a 4 o'clock showtime every day, and we still did well enough that they held us over and gave us better showtimes. That kept us in theaters for the two weeks between our first release date and October 30th.

On October 30th we launched on another 10 screens. Because of the work we'd done on the tour, in three of those 10 theaters we were the number one new release in the building, and in the top seven at the box office, on one showtime a day.

So the plan worked, just not at the scale we hoped for. If we'd launched on 25 screens, I think we'd have seen similar results everywhere. If we'd known we could expand, we could have launched our nationwide press and media. We held those back, because we were only in a limited number of cities and didn't want to waste attention on media people couldn't act on.

Why we couldn't expand

All but two of our theaters were a 50-50 split. We did well, the theaters were pleased, and everybody was happy with the results. It was just a smaller result than we wanted.

We weren't able to expand for two reasons.

One, we weren't in the top three as we'd planned, so with limited showtimes we didn't have crazy numbers.

Two, the box office got really, really crowded. When we chose our dates back in the summer, there were only two movies coming out on October 2nd, and October wasn't a full calendar. By the time we released, there were 13 new releases on October 9th, 22 on October 16th and 18 on October 22nd. All of those had holdovers that the studios require theaters to play.

Even taking our week-one numbers to other theaters, they appreciated it, and they physically could not say yes. They had more movies they were committed to play than they had screens. Even the 30-plexes we called back asking for a holdover said they didn't have room for us. A lot of people told us they don't have room until the new year.

So the lesson holds from the other side too: if you can deliver the math, they'll respond positively. Unless there's simply no room.

What I learned

It takes a lot more than you think. We spent money on marketing and on the tour, and we spent the previous 11 months lining up partners and supporters in every city. I think we were unclear on the ask. It wasn't just to support the film emotionally. It was to invite people, fill showtimes and help get the word out for the tour events. We didn't get the support we needed in the way we needed it.

That was a domino effect. We got a fifth to half of the people we wanted at the tour events, so everything after was smaller. We got about a tenth of the pre-sales, partly because in some cities we didn't even tell people about pre-sales, since we weren't sure there was enough support to open there. Instead of 25 cities, we were in 12. I still feel really good about that, given I had never been a theatrical booker or called a theater buyer in my life.

It takes longer than you think. We gave our booker the final cut in mid-September and asked for an October 9th opening. Nobody I booked a theater with asked to see a screener first. Not a single one. It does matter to have the movie finished and on a DCP, so you can say confidently where it's being sent from and how they'll receive it. But do you need it to start making calls? No.

Every yes is leverage to get the next yes. One booked date becomes the pitch for the next. The catch is that if your first one doesn't work out, it's hard to get the next one. So I'd only lean on this if you can book theaters you've sold out before you book them.

The order of operations. Build the demand, then supply the demand. Lock one confirmed date at one theater that can decide this week. Announce it. Activate everyone you have. Fill the room. Then use that footprint for the next booking. The process works. Where you'll run into hiccups is who you're asking to manufacture the demand.

You can do this with independent theaters, too. There are places where you can rent a theater for $400 to $700 on a weeknight. Book one night, get everybody in that city to go, and sell out 100 seats. At $17 a ticket that's $1,700 on a $500 rental, so you'd profit $1,200. That's more than you'd make on a $2,000 week at a 50-50 split, and $2,000 in a week is a good result! So there's a viable path to booking theaters on your own, just know that many of the larger chains charge full price for every seat in the theater, so it could be $1700 or more for a rental.

After we were told there were no more first runs available, we pivoted to four-walling. We've screened in Sacramento and Orlando, we have Minneapolis, Indianapolis, DC, San Diego and Dallas lined up (check brotherhoodmovie.com/tickets for the current list), and we're working our way through the rest of the tour cities so everyone who wanted to see it in theaters gets the chance.

The industry trained us to wait

The industry trained filmmakers to wait: for a festival, a sales agent, a distributor. To be chosen.

There's a caveat: You can build a lot of press and awareness for a movie on the festival route. If you treat festivals as awareness and reserve the theatrical release for yourself, you can make that work. If you go to festivals hoping for a distribution deal, unless you're in a decent festival it's unlikely, and you're still handing the responsibility for distribution and sales to someone else.

On small indie films, especially under $100,000, you can realistically do it yourself. If you can make $1,000 per screening and do 100 of them in a year, you don't need to pay a distributor a 15 to 30% fee. My friend Bryson is doing exactly that with his movie Eddie Arnold Is a Loser, which screened at South by Southwest and has done really well in its theatrical release, and he can keep building awareness with that film over time.

On a multi-million-dollar indie, you need a lot more showtimes and tickets than that. For a film our size, on 50-50 splits, we'd have needed at least $5 million at the box office, so call it $6 million, to break even. Divided by $16, about the average evening ticket right now, that's 375,000 tickets. You're not going to sell out every show, so call it 50 tickets per showtime: that's 7,500 showtimes. At seven a week, that's more than a thousand screens for one week, or 500 for two weeks, or about 350 for three. It's more than you think.

But on a movie under $200,000, doing the road show version, renting theaters for a few hundred dollars and selling them out, that's a really great option.

So theatrical does reward going first, in the sense of going and proving the demand. It isn't the act of going direct that they reward. It's the certainty you bring with you. Like I've been saying for the last couple of years, a producer's job isn't just to bring a good movie to theaters anymore. It's to bring the audience along with it. When you do that, you've created certainty, and you can book theaters off that certainty.

Going first

It takes a mindset shift. You have to be willing to go all in on something with a low probability of success. That's what being an entrepreneur is, and that's what being a producer is. Every movie is a low-probability outcome. That's the industry we work in.

Even for the studios, the hit rate isn't that high. Stephen Follows tracked every US film with a public budget from 1990 to 2015, and only about 37% were very likely to have made money, and that counts every revenue stream, from theaters to TV.[1]

For independents it's worse. Of more than 37,000 US independent films released between 1999 and 2018, nine out of ten never played in a commercial theater at all, and a randomly chosen one had about a 3.4% chance of making its backers money.[2] Even among the indies that did reach theaters, fewer than a third turned a profit.[2]

So you have to be OK with uncertainty, and with a landscape that changes daily based on how the market's responding to every film in it. Our plan was a good plan on paper. And when it broke, we pivoted. We got the movie into theaters when we were told it wasn't possible.

In select theaters

Every indie poster says "in select theaters." Who did the selecting?

This time, we did.

Here's where I've landed: It's possible. It takes more than you think, and it's harder than you think. You need a plan, and the plan exists. I've run it. It worked in the theaters we had, and it keeps working, because we still have more demand than supply in the marketplace. As long as that's true, you can be profitable. I can keep booking theaters city by city through the holidays and into next year if we have to.

I can still see the thousands of requests, and dozens more still come in every day. I can see the people who haven't been able to see the movie yet, and I get to decide how to serve them. Many want to see it in theaters, and we're working on that. Many will want to see it at home, and we're working on that too. We're also considering an event-style release with a different distributor for one week in January, so everyone who wanted to see it in theaters has the chance.

That's the great thing about being independent. You have control over how you deal with the uncertainty and complexity of the marketplace. You're not beholden to a distributor. Nobody tells you, too bad, that's how it went. You're in control of everything you can control, and that's an empowering place for an independent filmmaker to be.

Am I looking to repeat it exactly this way? Not necessarily. Movies deserve to be seen in theaters. My original goal was a million people seeing this one in theaters. So far it's a few thousand. We have a long way to go, and we have plans, some of them new as of this week.

I'd also argue this release put more money in our investors' hands than a comparable studio-style release would have. Imagine a partner who spends $5 million marketing a film and recoups it in first position. You'd have to gross more than $10 million before you see any money. Even with our small release, I've been able to put five figures of revenue back into our bank account. There are hundreds of movies every year that never earn back the marketing that was paid out in first position, which leaves the filmmakers 100% reliant on everything after theatrical to be made whole.

You can call that hitting a target and painting a bullseye around it. But the reality is we made money on our theatrical release, paid directly to us. It underperformed my hopes and even my plan, and I still came out further ahead than I would have with a traditional release and a marketing budget paid back first.

The principle still holds: you want more demand than supply. Build the demand, then go supply it.

The demand page and the request-a-theater tool we built for Brotherhood are in the Craftsman Fellowship toolkit.


Sources

  1. Stephen Follows, “Do Hollywood movies make a profit?” (2016)
  2. Stephen Follows, “What percentage of independent films are profitable?” (2019)