9 min read

Why Is It So Hard to Get Theaters to Book Indie Films? (Part 1)

Why Is It So Hard to Get Theaters to Book Indie Films? (Part 1)
Photo by Felix Mooneeram / Unsplash

I told you I'd give you the real updates as they happen, so here we are. It's a few weeks late, because that's what happened to our theatrical release.

When I wrote last in September, we were gearing up for a theatrical run starting October 9th. That didn't happen the way we expected. I'll tell you what did happen and what I'm learning in real time, because independent filmmakers need to operate from a place of clarity rather than hope.

This isn't a complaint. It's a report from the front lines, from someone who took over the theatrical booking of his own independent film to get it into as many theaters as possible.

We - incorrectly - think that if we can get distribution, we'll make money. We think the only yes we need is from a distributor. In reality there are a number of yeses. You need a yes from a distributor, even if you give yourself that yes and take it on yourself. You need yeses from the theaters that will show your movie. And most importantly, you need yeses from the audience who will buy the ticket, show up, and tell others about it.

I'm in the middle of booking Brotherhood: A Cinematic Musical as I write this. There's one thing I've learned over the last few months that I want you to repeat after me until you've memorized it:

Theaters don’t book demand, they book certainty.
That’s why the showtimes go to the studios.

The math of a breakout

Let's say you want a breakout: a $10 million box office on a movie that cost $2 million or less.

At an average ticket of $15, that's 666,667 tickets.

If you average 15 people a showtime (a room that's about 10% full), you need 44,000 showtimes.

If you get a one-week run with one showtime a day, that's seven showtimes per theater. So you'd need about 6,300 theaters. That's more theater locations than the U.S. has. The biggest releases this year opened in 4,400 or 4,500 theaters, and they came with $100 million marketing budgets and the leverage to play on multiple screens for multiple weeks.

So a breakout has to come from more showtimes per theater, more weeks, and fuller rooms, all at once. Independents have no leverage on two of those.

We don't decide how many showtimes we get. We don't decide how many weeks we play. And what we're given decides how many people we can get to the theater. One showtime means everyone has to be free that night. One showtime at 4 o'clock means losing everyone who works until 5 or 6.

Your box office is theaters x showtimes x people. The only one we have any impact or control over is people per showtime, and even that depends on the showtimes we're given. The buyer controls the other two, and the buyer books on certainty.

Their job is to make their theater money, so they book the movies with the best chance of filling the most seats at every showtime. More tickets means more box office, and more importantly, more concessions. One consultant told me theaters pay their bills on the weekends and on discount Tuesdays. The rest of the week, they're empty.

I've seen it. We've done private screenings on Wednesdays and Thursdays and brought in 30, 50, 80, 100 people, and the rest of the building had six or eight people in it. Total.

Despite this, the theaters still have to run these studio movies because the studios dictate the terms of the agreement. How many screens, how many showtimes per day, whether the screen can be shared (it can't 99% of the time), the revenue split between them and the theater (often in the studio's favor), and how many weeks the theaters have to play the movie.

All of that leaves independents in a tough spot. There often aren't enough screens to fulfill their commitments with the studios, and there is no room left in the building to screen an indie film.

But what about the audience?

The common belief among independents - myself included - is that if you build enough audience, the theaters will come. That's where I messed up.

We spent our marketing dollars on a three-week promotional tour: our two leads, our writer-director, our cultural consultant, me, a tour producer, and a technical director. Sixteen cities plus three premieres. We reached thousands of people and got them to pre-order tickets, request a theater, and join our email list, so we could prove demand in the marketplace.

I'll tell you from the get-go: my goal numbers for that tour were an order of magnitude more than what we ended up with. Coming out with 10,000 pre-orders is a very different story than 1,000. Part of that's on me, part of it's our timeline, part of it's our budget. We got what we got, and we entered the marketplace with a much smaller audience than the plan needed.

But look at what we did have: over 1,500 theater requests, the tour, and presales. And when we started asking theaters for showtimes, we were told there was no room.

This created an unfortunate situation: everyone waiting on everyone else.

You can't book your movie without the movie being done. Our screener wasn't finished until mid-September, so our theatrical booker had three or four weeks to do a job that takes three or four months. You can't book it without proof of an audience. You can't activate the audience without showtimes to send them to. You can't get press or influencers without dates. You can't tell your own cast and crew without screens. You can't raise the money without a release plan, and you can't make a release plan without the money.

And there's a cost to getting it wrong. You spend the audience's excitement before there's a ticket to buy. You teach fans your dates aren't real. And one weak showtime becomes the number every next buyer reads when they look you up. They see it and think, it's fine, not great. That's uncertainty, and buyers don't book uncertainty.

Opening weekend

The goal was 25 cities, one theater per city. I was hoping for a traditional run of five showtimes a day, but I was open to one a day as long as it was in the evening. At least seven showtimes per city, ideally 35.

What we got from our distribution partner was one showtime at one theater, near one of our tour markets but not in it.

We sold 44% of that room. When the average movie runs 10 to 15% full, that's three to four times better. But it was one showtime in one theater, when the goal was 25 cities.

That's when I realized, too late, that this wasn't going to work the way we'd asked it to work. It's also why I haven't written to you. I spent the last month figuring out what to do about it.

I now understand that the big chains are built for wide releases. They're structurally optimized to put studio movies in theaters: movies with a ton of awareness, a big marketing budget, and the leverage of a studio behind them. When you ask for one screen in one city (or in our case, 25 cities), it honestly takes more work than a wide release. For the studio movie they click a button. For us, someone has to pick the theater, the showtime, and the city.

The workaround people suggest is to go to the independents. The independent and arthouse theaters, the one-, two- and four-screen houses, would love to show your movie. But they build their programming months in advance: repertory screenings, events, private groups. When we called in early October for late October or November, they were booked through the end of the year.

That left the mid-tier chains: regional circuits with a few dozen theaters. They book first-run studio films, but they book week to week, not three months out, and they may have enough screens to find you a shared screen and one showtime a day. Like Goldilocks: the big chains are too big, the single screens are too small, and you want something in the middle.

How a booking decision really gets made

A theater buyer is filling a finite grid of screens and showtimes, week by week. Studio titles arrive with contracts: clean-screen terms (that movie plays on that screen all day, five times a day), a number of weeks it has to hold over, and the P&A the studio is committing. Those screens are spoken for before you've even found the right person to call.

On Mondays, buyers decide what's being held over. Then they look at what's new. What they've been seeing for a month or two is that the holdovers plus the new releases are already more than they have screens. A theater with 8, 10, even 13 screens might have obligations to 18, 20, 25 movies. That's what "there's no room" means.

The 7 p.m. slot is where they make their money, and everybody wants it. Matinees don't sell, which is why they're discounted. Theaters split every ticket about 50-50 with the distributor, but they keep 100% of concessions.

And per-screen average is how a buyer gets judged. An unknown indie is a risk to that number. Even when we sold out our evening shows and sold more tickets than anything else in the building, our weekly number was small. Making $2,000 in a week on one showtime a day is really impressive. In some theaters it made us the number one new release, and on a Tuesday or Wednesday night, the number one movie in the building. But at the end of the week you made $2,000, and half goes to the theater. All that work for $1,000.

If you make $1,000 per theater per week and you want a $10 million box office, how many theater-weeks do you need? Is that even realistic? 

Why the system is built this way

The studios solved the chicken-and-egg problem with time and money. They commit release dates 8 to 16 months out and announce summer slates at CinemaCon well ahead. The Odyssey put its IMAX tickets on sale a year before release and sold them out. They picked the date before the movie was finished, with a studio machine, the money, and the relationships to make it work.

Independents show up with demand and no date. In a system that runs on dates, that doesn't make sense. Sometimes you can get in next week. Most of the time they say no, we're overcommitted. What they're telling you is, you're asking me to do too much.

Also consider that the buyer gets no credit for your hit and all the blame for an empty room. If someone gives your movie a chance and it sells 20 tickets and makes $300 for the week, that was a bad decision. So they're looking for reasons to say no, so they can say yes to movies that will make more money than yours.

Some theaters do read demand differently. In Utah we had nearly 500 pre-sold tickets. When we showed up with that plus hundreds of theater requests, and showed them each request represents five tickets and thousands of dollars in revenue, they perked up. That's how we got six theaters in Utah to give us a week of showtimes, and we ended up the #1 new release in two of them. Where we only had a handful of presales and requests, it wasn't enough. Telling a theater you pre-sold five tickets is $75. Who cares?

Being the independent

It's hard to be unknown. It's hard to be told no for reasons that have nothing to do with your work.But it's also freeing.

The no isn't a verdict on your film, it's a verdict on the marketplace. This fall the studios were releasing a lot of movies they'd held through the summer because of the World Cup, at least that's my read on it. It was a crowded market, and the no came often because they had no room for us.

Certainty has to come from somewhere, and no one else in the chain is going to make it for you.

Where we had it, it worked. In the ten cities we opened in that I booked, the demand was there, and we got the yes, the theater, the showtimes, and the audience. Three of those ten theaters held us over for another week, despite a pile of new movies, because in a 20-plex, if you're the number seven movie by box office on one showtime a day and the number one new release, they're going to keep you.

It's a principle I've tried to live by in my businesses for over a decade: be so good they can't ignore you.

The system is waiting

The system isn't against you. It's waiting for certainty, and it isn't going to create it for you.

You have to understand the physics of a theatrical release and align with it. If you operate by the way you hope it works, you won't get the outcomes you want. So it comes down to three things: understand how it works, align with it, and architect a plan that can work anyway, as an independent with no A-list cast and no $100 million marketing budget.

Hope is not a strategy. Distribution is not the goal. Full theaters are the goal, and full theaters are the only thing that moves everyone in the chain. If you can show how you'll fill theaters, you can get distribution, theaters, showtimes, and an audience that shows up. Whoever you need a yes from, you have to give them certainty. Not bravado or a passionate pitch, but real certainty based on proven demand for your film.

In part two, I'll write about how we pivoted and what we did about it on Brotherhood: A Cinematic Musical.